We walk through some of the theories we’ve developed about how Ralph Otto might have been able to conceal a... more

We spend time detailing what was and what wasn’t found inside the shallow grave where the Finley Creek Jane Doe... more

As a second search dog comes on the scene to hunt for missing pieces of the Jane Doe’s skeleton, we... more

Hunters found a murdered woman in the woods in 1978. Investigators were never able to identify her, however Patty Otto’s... more

The only confirmed witness to what happened the night Patty Otto vanished was her youngest daughter. We’ll listen as she... more

The strange details of things that happened in the weeks after Patty vanished leave us with even more questions. Was... more

As rumors begin swirling about Patty’s whereabouts and why she may have vanished, Ralph’s psyche seems to be unraveling. Is... more

Ralph Otto’s accounts of what happened the night his wife disappeared changed with each retelling. Ralph’s allies had explanations for... more

In 1976, a Lewiston, Idaho, woman mysteriously vanished one night and was presumably murdered. Almost exactly two years later, a... more

In this Season 1 bonus episode, we discuss new information about potential suspects provided by our listeners and the producer... more