pod.link copied!
But Make It Scary
But Make It Scary
Sequoia Thomas

But Make It Scary is a dark comedy podcast that twists hit romantic films into the horror movies you didn’t know you... more

Listen now on

Apple Podcasts
Google Podcasts
Podcast Addict
Pocket Casts
Player FM
Podcast Republic


52. Mamma Mia (w/JD Fierce)

Go check out Pokemakers wherever pods are cast! Find 45 more minutes of this episode as well as some... more

30 Nov 2022 · 1 hour, 1 minute
51. Kate & Leopold (w/Kevin McCaffrey and Jon Daly)

Go check out The Bridgerton Bros and Sex and the Cidiots whever pods are cast! Looking for 30 more minutes... more

16 Nov 2022 · 1 hour, 11 minutes
50. 50 First Dates (w/Alex Fierce)

Go check out Pokemakers wherever pods are cast! Check out 45 additional minutes of this episode at patreon.com/butmakeitscary Get merch,... more

02 Nov 2022 · 1 hour, 3 minutes
49. But Make it Christmas: Carrie (1976) (w/Mike Schubert)

Go check out The Newest Olympian, Modern Muckraker, Horse, Meddling Adults, or Potterless wherever you listen to podcasts! Find the... more

31 Oct 2022 · 53 minutes
48. The Princess Diaries 2: Royal Engagement (w/Alyssa Esteban)

Go check out Breakfast in Beauclair for some great Witcher content! Find anything you might need at @butmakeitscary or butmakeitscary.com

21 Oct 2022 · 51 minutes
47. You've Got Mail (w/Eric Scull)

Go listen to MuggleCast and Thank You For Spieling!   Check out https://www.patreon.com/butmakeitscary for 50 more minutes of this episode...... more

05 Oct 2022 · 1 hour, 5 minutes
46. Pretty in Pink (w/Marcella Pereda)

It's another bonus ep feed drop! If you want access to another 8 bonus episodes, 30 directors cuts, 15 creature... more

21 Sep 2022 · 1 hour, 1 minute
45. 27 Dresses (w/Happily Ever Aftermath)

Go check out Happily Ever Aftermath wherever pods are cast!    Find anything you may need at butmakeitscary.com

09 Sep 2022 · 57 minutes
44. Up in the Air (w/Andrew Sims)

Go check out Mugglecast and Millennial!   Find the patreon at https://www.patreon.com/butmakeitscary   Find everything else at butmakeitscary.com

24 Aug 2022 · 44 minutes
43. Breakfast at Tiffany's (w/Geoff)

Check out Into the Fold wherever pods are cast! Join BMiS on patreon for extended editions of the episodes as... more

06 Jul 2022 · 54 minutes
But Make It Scary
52. Mamma Mia (w/JD Fierce)
But Make It Scary